When I write this way, like I am doing here on
this blog, I feel like I am following the Holy Spirit. That is, when I do this work of trying to search out lessons from the walk of faith to see if they can be fit into useful paragraphs, I feel the Spirit bearing fruit. The fruits of the Spirit are named in Galatians 5:22-23—a list that includes love, joy, peace, and patience. When I seek God through this kind of composition, I experience all of these characteristics in greater measure. The people who have to deal with me are among the beneficiaries.
Yet the skeptic might argue that there’s nothing spiritual in this. The effect is purely material. The effect is endorphins. Writing just triggers the good chemicals in my brain.
Maybe. I’m not much moved by that argument. The fruits of the Spirit can have a physical component—
God is more real than my body. The argument that “it’s all purely physical” still does nothing to explain how an election on my part—the choice of one pursuit out of many I might have chosen—could drive these material shifts in the physicality of my body.
However, there is another objection the skeptic might raise that does give me greater pause. Namely: Writing has
always been with me. It was a part of my life before I believed in Christ. I have found something new to do with my writing, but I have always derived love, joy, peace, and patience from the attempt to try to capture ideas in paragraphs.
So if I have always had these fruits, where then is the Spirit?
The LineThe question is meaningful, because scripture suggests there ought to be a clear line of demarcation involving the Spirit’s relationship with us. Peter draws the line in his speech at the Pentecost in Acts 2. “Repent and be baptized,” he says, “and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit” (Acts 2:38).
I believe I have repented. I have also been baptized. However, there has been no personal Pentecost I could discern. At the time of my baptism or later on, there was no wind rushing in, and nothing like the flame or foreign language discernment that Acts 2 described.
Therefore: Did I do something wrong?
The clear line of division can be just as elusive if we ever try to distinguish which people have the Holy Spirit. Since love is first among the fruits of the Spirit, the believers in Christ ought to have more love than those who do not believe—correct?
I do see professing Christians who are profoundly loving. Their love is part of what persuaded me to join them. But not all are this way. Then, I take note of the wonderfully loving people who apparently have no interest in Jesus Christ. I know a person like this; I bet you do, too. What are we to make of the discrepancy?
Does the indwelling of the Holy Spirit have a meaningful impact or not?
All these questions feel a little like elephants in the church. We believe in the Holy Spirit, but we’re not necessarily sure what that belief means. Yet the questions are worth exploring for that very reason. One of the teachings of Jesus that remains the most startlingly profound is that there is this other facet of God—this God who comes to live with us. We are to seek God, and that includes seeking the God who is both mysterious and powerfully near.
He Reveals Himself
I think the beginning of an answer to these questions can be found in a distinction—a seemingly small difference that actually has profound importance. We tend to confuse the Holy Spirit with the
manifestations of the Holy Spirit.
The Holy Spirit is everywhere. See Psalm 139:7-8. It is therefore meaningless to say that we could ever “sense” or “detect” his presence—that presence is ubiquitous. However, the Holy Spirit does sometimes assert himself in ways that we do sense, or can perceive. When he does this, he does it for one reason. He manifests his presence for the “common good” or the “benefit of all” (1 Corinthians 12:7).
The Pentecost of Acts 2 was for the benefit of all. Jesus had just left. He went to heaven. The church was left behind, and it is difficult to imagine what this loss must have felt like. A profound loneliness must have set in, the loneliness that God is gone. But then, as if on cue, the Holy Spirit showed up. He showed up vividly—uniting the body of believers through a common language, and spiritually igniting them with tongues of flame. This was the Pentecost, and it would be hard to argue that the event did not serve the common good.
The situation is different today. We have the scriptures. We have the testimonies of those who have come before us. If every one of us today obtained a clear and predictable sign at the moment we “joined,” then we would not be part of Christ’s body by faith, but by validation.
Imagine also what we might do with this information. If all believers had some mark of the Spirit in their lives that was both clear and predictable, then it would be easy (easier than it already is!) to pigeonhole people according to a view of who is “in” and who is not. Perhaps the common good is better served today by a situation in which Christians are sometimes challenged by the sight of non-Christians who seem to be bearing more of the Spirit’s fruit.
Back ThenAs we have already seen from the reference to Psalm 139, the Spirit was apparent to people in the Old Testament. Indeed, Psalm 51:11 offers a plea:
Do not take your Holy Spirit from me. The Holy Spirit was present back then—and I think something similar is true for the “back then” of my own life. The Holy Spirit was with me, even manifest, before I believed in Christ.
How could this not be the case?
Yes, I was rejecting God. But God kept calling.
Yes, I was rejecting the One whose love and authority should have been obvious—but this is the God who pursues his lost sheep (Luke 15:4). This is the God who
showers blessings on believers and nonbelievers alike (Matthew 5:45).
Of course his Spirit touched me and of course his Spirit even came to my aid! His Spirit showed me what more I could have had, if only I had welcomed him. Instead, back then, I simply took the blessings and indulged in them before I turned back again to going my own way.
Do Not Take Your Spirit AwaySomething decisive did happen at Pentecost.
As discussed in a previous post, there is a statement from Jesus (Luke 11:13) that makes little sense unless the Holy Spirit is something of which it is possible for us to have “more.” That is, the Holy Spirit within us can increase. Consider this in light of what Peter said. He did not speak of the “arrival” of the Holy Spirit. He did not make an introduction. Rather, he spoke of a gift that had been given, a gift of the Holy Spirit, a gift that changed the nature of the Spirit’s relationship with us.
Something decisive happened at Pentecost, and something decisive happened with my own baptism and belief. I have been searching for manifestations of the Holy Spirit in my own life of faith—ways that the Spirit has reshaped my life and character.
I think I have found them. However, I do not include these fruits I experience through writing as part of this list. I was fortunate enough to have those before I had faith.
Rather than the Spirit appearing for the first time at my baptism, I believe the decisive thing that happened is this: The plea of Psalm 51 was heard. God did not take his Holy Spirit away. He did not take the manifestations away.
In fact, God took away the very fear that the Holy Spirit would be taken. This is the fear that the nonbeliever lives with, without even knowing its name.
At Pentecost, the current and future believers in Christ got something that was genuinely new. They received a door in their hearts, a door at which they could always search and knock. This door will always open—so long as we truly want
the gifts that the Holy Spirit gives.
We do have to seek, we do have to ask, and we do have to knock. But the connection—the way by which we can invite God to enter our hearts and lives—remains ours. From the first day of faith forward, the amount of the Holy Spirit in our lives can only increase.